SUBJECT: The sealing of mixers and agitators 3-7

Mixer applications are the same as process pump applications, except for a couple of things:

Please refer to the following drawing for the bearing arrangement of a typical mixer. You'll note that the motor turns the shaft through some gearing that's well supported by bearings. The problem starts when the mixer shaft passes through the stuffing box area.

As the impeller turns in the liquid it can cause excessive shaft whip and radial movement. As shown in figure "A" the packing helps to stabilize the shaft and is acting as another support bearing. Packing never was designed to act as a bearing so the result is major shaft wear and excessive leakage problems. The shaft movement is aggravated by several factors:

If you attempt to convert mixer packing to a mechanical seal you usually run into trouble with the excessive shaft motion. Some consumers have attempted to solve the motion problem by installing another anti- friction bearing closer to the mechanical seal. Unless the equipment is "line bored" (and it never is) it's not wise to put three anti- friction bearings on any rotating shaft.

Picture "B" is one method of solving the problem. The mixer shaft is placed inside a "Quill Shaft" that's well supported by bearings and this quill shaft is then coupled to the mixer shaft. This design will allow the manufacture to place the second shaft bearing closer to the stuffing box area where it should have been in the first place. Unfortunately this new design adds several thousand dollars to the mixer cost. The manufacture typically packages a double seal and bearing into a spool piece that can be inserted into the two piece shaft.

This original equipment seal is a poor choice because most mixer manufacturers choose an inferior unbalanced "back to back" double seal that'll damage the expensive stub shaft and clog easily if there are solids in the mixing liquid. The following illustration describes this " back to back" double seal:

As the seal faces wear and the inner seal attempts to move forward, it will hang up on the solids collected in front of the inside rotating face. Centrifugal force will throw the solids into the inside faces causing excessive wear in a short period of time.

The best, and lowest cost solution is to install a motion seal in the stuffing box and solve the problem once and for all. I do not have an illustration for a motion seal, but you can check with your seal supplier for a catalog that'll explain the seal in great detail.

Motion seals are different than pump seals:

Single split seals, mounted on a split sleeve, have become very popular for mixer type applications (see the following illustration). The shaft movement can be partially stabilized by installing a split sleeve bearing in the stuffing box. A wide variety of materials are available for this split bearing. Check with your local distributor.

The split seal is also a good choice for those mixers that have a moveable shaft that seals a Teflon ring against the tank wall and allows you to change the seal without emptying the mixer. This is a major improvement over the original equipment design because you do not have to remove the shaft spool piece.

It should be obvious that when the spool piece is removed, there's usually no force to hold the Teflon® ring against the mixer wall.

Bottom entering shafts create a different set of problems. Look at the following illustration:

Dirt and solids fall into the stuffing box and can't be centrifuged out. Flushing liquid tends to channel through the solids and does a poor job of removing them from the stuffing box.

There are a couple of possible solutions.

For information about my CD with over 600 Seal & Pump Subjects explained, click here

Link to Mc Nally home page